IHS - People

People at IHS in alphabetical order:

  • Mag. Dr. PhD Anna Durnova

    • Insight Austria
    Senior Researcher
    +43 1 59991 198
    durnova(at)ihs.ac.at
  • Sociology of Emotions

    Sociology of Health

    Public Policy

    Cultural Sociology

    Critical Policy Studies

    Expertise and Knowledge
     

  • Bild Anna Durnova
  • Anna Durnová is a public policy scholar and Elise Richter Research Fellow at the research group Insight Austria. She researches the interplays of emotions and knowledge in politics using examples from health, science and social policies. The main interest of this work is to understand the current societal polarizations better, in particular the conditions of legitimacy of expertise and the way citizen engage with expertise in democratic societies. 

    Beyond her appointment at IHS, Anna is also coordinates a project at the Institute of Sociological Studies in Prague. She is also Faculty Fellow at the Yale Center for Cultural Sociology and Forum Editor of Critical Policy Studies (CPS). She is also part of the Leadership collective of the Critical Policy Studies Group, at the American Political Science Association, gathering critical scholars in public policy and political sociology.

    Anna Durnová has been quiet active internationally: she was a Visiting researcher at Concordia university in 2019, Visiting Professor  at the Masaryk University Brno in 2012 and between 2009 and 2010 I was a Lecturer and Researcher at the University of Lyon. She also holds her Habilitation Diplomar from the Sciences PO Paris.

    Her work on policy includes also number of advisory activities and leadership functions: She is Chair of the Ethical Commission of the Institute for Advanced Studies and Director of the Board of the Institute of international Relations in Prague. She is also Member of the ELSI Common Service, the expert network of BBMRI-ERIC.

    Find more up-to-date information here

  • click here for the full publication list

    Books

    Durnová, A. (2019). Understanding emotions in post-factual politics: negotiating truth.  Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing. 

    Durnová, A. (2018).  The Politics of Intimacy. Rethinking the End-of-life Controversy. Ann Arbor: The University of Michigan Press. 

    Durnová, A. (2015) In den Händen der Ärzte. Ignaz Philipp Semmelweis – Pionier der Handhygiene.  Wien, Residenzverlag.

    Fischer, F., Torgerson, D., Durnová, A., & Orsini, M. (2015) (Eds.). Handbook of Critical Policy Studies. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing. https://dx.doi.org/10.4337/9781783472352

    Articles in Peer reviewed journals

    Durnová, Anna P. and Christopher M. Weible. 2020. Tempest in a Teapot? Toward New Collaborations between Mainstream Policy Process Studies and Interpretive Policy Studies, Policy Sciences, online first , DOI: 10.1007/s11077-020-09386-z

    Ercan, S. A., Durnová, A., Loeber, A., & Wagenaar, H. (2020). Symposium: revisiting the three pillars of Deliberative Policy Analysis. Policy Studies, 1-24.

    Weible, Christopher M., Daniel Nohrstedt, Paul Cairney, David P. Carter, Deserai A. Crow, Anna P. Durnová, Tanya Heikkila, Karin Ingold, Allan McConnell, and Diane Stone. 2020. "COVID-19 and the policy sciences: initial reactions and perspectives."  Policy Sciences, online first:  doi: 10.1007/s11077-020-09381-4.

    Durnová  A. (2019) Unpacking emotional contexts of post-truthCritical Policy Studies, 13:4, 447-450.

    Durnová, A. (2019). March for Science als Schauplatz der gesellschaftspolitischen Polarisierung zwischen Elite und Volk: ein interpretativer Beitrag zur Analyse von Postfaktizität., Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft 29 (2): 345-360. 

    Goisauf, Melanie Gillian Martin, Heidi Beate Bentzen, Isabelle Budin-Ljøsne, Lars Ursin, Anna Durnova, Liis Leitsalu, Katharine Smith, Sara Casati1, Marialuisa Lavitrano, Deborah Mascalzoni, Martin Boeckhout, Michaela Th. Mayrhofer (2019): “Data in Question: A Survey of European Biobank Professionals on Ethical, Legal and Societal Challenges of Biobank Research”, PLOS ONE 14 (9): e0221496. 

    Durnová, A. (2019) Czech Post-communist Trouble with Participatory Governance. Toward an Analysis of the Cultural Agency of Policy Discourses, Policy Studies, online first

    Goisauf M. & Durnová A.  (2019). From Engaging Publics to Engaging Knowledges: Enacting “Appropriateness” in the Austrian Biobank Infrastructure, Public Understanding of Science, 28(3), 275–289,

    Durnová, A. (2018). Understanding Emotions in Policy Studies through Foucault and Deleuze, Politics & Governance, 2018, Volume 6, Issue 4, Pages 95–102.

    Durnová, A. (2018). A Tale of ‘Fat Cats’ and ‘Stupid Activists’: Contested Values, Governance and Reflexivity in the Brno Railway Station Controversy. Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 20 (6), 735 - 751.

    Durnová A. and Hejzlarová E. (2017). Framing policy designs through contradictory emotions: The case of Czech single mothers, Public Policy and Administration, Vol. 33 (4), pp. 409-427.

    Durnová, A. (2016). Reading the End-of-life Controversy through Political Lenses: Public Power and Intimacy. Sociální studia / Social Studies, 1/2016, 87–100.

    Durnová, A. (2015). Between the Individual and the collective: Understanding the tensions of the interpretive inquiry. A Response to Boswell and Corbett. Critical Policy Studies, 9(2), 241–246.

    Durnová, A., & Zittoun, P. (2013). Les approches discursives des politiques publiques [Discursive Approaches to Public Policy]. Revue française de science politique, 63(3/2013), 569–577.

    Durnová, A. (2013). Governing Through Intimacy: Explaining Care Policies Through ‘Sharing A Meaning’. Critical Social Policy, 33(3), 496–515.

    Durnová, A. (2012). Über die Rationalität hinaus: für eine interpretative und politische Wissenschaft. Reaktion auf Andreas Dür. Österreichische Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft, 41(3), 315–322.

    Book chapters:

    Durnová, A. (2018). Intimität regieren (lassen)? Politischer Diskurs zum Lebensende in der postindustriellen Gesellschaft, In: Willibald J. Stronegger, Kristin Attems (Eds.): Mensch und Endlichkeit. Wien: Nomos Verlag, Reihe Bioethik in Wissenschaft und Gesellschaft", pp. 57 – 77.

    Durnová, A. (2017). Může se česká politika obrátit jiným směrem? Kulturněsociologická sebereflexe jedné generace. In V. M. Dostál, Grigorij (Ed.), Maximum možného? (pp. 137 - 143). Praha: Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung e.V.

    Durnová, A., Fischer, F., & Zittoun P. (2016). Discursive Approaches to Public Policy: Politics, Argumentation, and Deliberation. In B. G. Peters & P. Zittoun (Eds.), Contemporary Approaches to Public Policy. Theories, Controversies and Perspectives (pp. 35–58). New York, NY: Palgrave Macmillan.

    Durnová, A. (2015). Lost in Translation: Expressing Emotions in Policy Deliberation. In F. Fischer, D. Torgerson, M. Orsini & A. Durnová (Eds.), Handbook of Critical Policy Studies (pp. 222–239). Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.

    Durnová, A. (2015). Planning through Emotions: Political Lessons from the Controversy Between ‘Fat Cats’ and ‘Stupid Activists’ over Rebuilding Brno Railroad Station. In E. Gualini, E. (Ed.), Planning and Conflict. Critical Perspectives on Contentious Urban Developments (pp. 259–278). New York, NY: Routledge.

    Durnová, A. (2011). L’État face aux “catastrophes morales”: de la politique de la mort en France au pouvoir de l’intime [State facing the Moral Catastrophe. Politics of death in France and the Power of intimacy]. In A. François (Ed.), Nouvelles figures de l’État. Violences, droit et société [New Figures of the State: Violence, Right and Society] (pp. 225–248). Cluj: ARCHES/Idea.

     

    Online Proceedings:

    Durnová, A. (2015). “Negotiating Truth: Semmelweis and the role of Emotions in Public Policy”, available online at: http://policyandpoliticsblog.com/2015/06/25/negotiating-truth-semmelweis-and-the-role-of-emotions-in-public-policy/#more-2381

    Durnová, A. (2014). “Negotiating Truth. Semmelweis, Discourse on Hand Hygiene and Politics of Emotions, available online at:  www.sis-e.org/downloads/SISE%202014%20Semmelweis%20Lecture_Negotiating%20Truth_Text.pdf

    Zittoun, P. & Durnová A. (2010). „l’Insoutenable de l’ordre du discours. ” [The unbearable of the order of discourse], In : Foucault dans les itinéraires des Recherches [Foucault in the Research trajectories], Working series Laboratoire PACTE, Grenoble.

    Book reviews:

    „Iva Šmídová, Eva Šlesingerová, Lenka Slepičková, Games of Life: Czech Reproductive Medicine, Sociological Perspectives, Masarykova univerzita, 2015“,  Sociální Studia/Social Studies, 3/2016

    „Helga Nowotny: The Cunning of Uncertainty, Polity Press 2016“, Sociologický časopis / Czech Sociological Review 4/2016, pp. 610 - 613.

    “Frank Fischer: Democracy and Expertise: Re-Orienting Policy Inquiry, Oxford university Press, 2009”. Österreichische Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft vol. 4 /2011, pp. 435 – 436.

    “Hendrik Wagenaar: Meaning in Action: Interpretation and Dialogue in Policy Process, M.E. Sharpe Inc. 2011”. Critical Policy Studies, Vol. 6 (1), pp. 103 – 105.

     

     

    Crafting liberal democracy through self-determination: the case of women’s health care choices - CLIDE  (Principal Investigator)

    Project Duration: 2019 - 2023 

    Project objective: The project looks at one of the key dimensions of self-determination – the public debates on health care choices – while zeroing in on women’s health specifically. Women’s health complicates the general acceptance of the importance of self-determination in health care choices. While patients are seen as increasingly engaged in decisions on health care measures, public debates on home birth or refusal of mammography screening as legitimate health care choices point to a necessity to explore more deeply the nexus between self-determination and the rational-irrational binary code through that self-determination gets articulated in these specific debates. With its analytical focus on concrete references to emotions in public debate and its interdisciplinary approach CLIDE becomes the first project to bring an interpretive study of citizens’ perspectives on liberal democratic paradigm, its undermining and its future prospects. 

    Through desk research and media review, as well as field-work based interpretive analysis CLIDE will bring material from two particular controversies - the debate on home birth in France and in the refusal of mammography screening in Austria.  Expert interviews and biographic-narrative inquiry focussing on particular references to emotions in these issues will then allow for precise zooming in on concrete standpoints and practices together with their qualification as ‘rational’/’irrational’ or ‘legitimate’/’illegitimate’. With this rich set of data, the project foregrounds the discursive capacity of references to emotions to legitimize collective action and reorients the understanding of self-determination in liberal democratic paradigm. Planned for three years’ time, CLIDE links the policy-oriented research focus of the host institution with the PI’s academic expertise on health, sociology of emotions and policy studies to undertake innovative analysis in highly pending areas of health care while offering up-to-date empirical material on liberal democracy. 

    Financing: Funded by the Elise-Richter Programme of the Austrian FWF Science Fund (V 761)

     
     

    Invited talks

    Durnová, A. (2020, June): Emotions in times of COVID-19. Doing interpretive research in pandemic times. Talk within a course "Covid-19: The Pandemic, Societies, and Governments",School of Public Affairs, University of Colorado, Denver, USA

    Durnová, A. (2019, September) : Emotions, Democracy and the Post-factual Threat to Expertise, Keynote Address, Disagreement, (in)tolerance and political discourse, Conference organized by the Centre for Ethics as Study in Human Value, University of Pardubice, Czech Republic.

    Durnová, A. (2019, June): Intimacy and the Politics of Expertise, Invited talk, Concordia University, Montreal, Canada.

    Durnová, A. (2018, March) : Understanding emotions in the postfactual world, Invited Talk at the Sociological Evenings, Faculty of Social Science, Prague.

    Durnová, A (2017, October): "Feeling Liebral Democracy: Toward a policy oriented cultural sociology of emotions", Invited Talk at the Institute of International Relations, Prague.

    Durnová, A (2017, October): Responsibility in a Leaderless World, Plenary Panel, at the 9th International Symposium: Responsibility in a Leaderless World,  Czech Foreign ministry, Prague

    Durnová, A. (2017, September): Intimität regieren? Politischer Diskurs zum Lebensende in der post- industriellen Gesellschaft., Interdisziplinäres Dialogforum Mensch und Endlichkeit
    Die Institutionalisierung des Lebensendes zwischen Wissenschaft und Lebenswelt, Netzwerk Lebensende

    Durnová, A. (2017, April): Culture of Truth: Emotions in a Post-factual World, Yale CCS Spring Conference

    Durnová, A. (2017, April)  Searching for Truth in Post-factual Times, Yale University Policy Lab

    Durnová, A. (2017, February) “Citizen Empowerment in Post-communist context”, TPol talk, University at Albany, SUNY, 9 February 2017

    Durnová, A. (2016, November)  “New European Orientalism”, Plenary Rountable, Institut für Wissenschaft der Menschen, Vienna, 16 November 2016.

    Durnová, A. (2016, May). “The Politics of Intimacy Re-thinking the End-of-Life Controversy”. Institute of International Relations. Prague (Czech Republic), 25 May 2016.

    Durnová, A. (2015, September). “Die gemeine Hand: Der Fall Semmelweis und die Entdeckung der Kontaktinfektion” [Semmelweis Case and the Emergence of the Contact Infection]. Keynote address at the Hygiene-Fortbildungstage, Meeting of the Austrian Association of Health Care (ÖGKV). Vienna (Austria), 21–22 September 2015.

    Durnová, A. (2015, January). “Intimacy and Politics: the Case of Homebirth”. Invited talk at the Masaryk University Brno. Brno (Czech Republic), 22 January 2015.

    Durnová, A. (2014, October). “Ignaz Semmelweis: Kampf um die Wahrheit” [“Semmelweis fight for the Truth: Female bodies and the hands of doctors”]. Plenary talk at the convention “Idee und Widerspruch – der medizinische Diskurs im Wien des 19. und angehenden 20. Jahrhunderts” [“Idea and contradiction – the medical discourse in Vienna in the 19th and early 20th century”]. Society of College of Physicians in Vienna, Vienna (Austria), 22 October 2014.

    Durnová, A. (2014, October). “Politics of Intimacy: Re-thinking the end-of-life controversies”. Plenary talk at the Masaryk University Brno. Brno (Czech Republic), 17 October 2014.

    Durnová, A. (2014, August). “Austria and the Czech Republic through the comparative eyes”. Keynote address at the International Summer School of Journalism (Invitation of the Austrian Embassy in the Czech Republic). Havlíčkův Brod (Czech Republic), 14 August 2014.

    Durnová, A. (2014, July). “Politics of Intimacy: Re-thinking the end-of-life controversies”. Keynote address at the Université libre de Bruxelles. Brussels (Belgium), 19 July 2014.

    Durnová, A. (2014, June). “Negotiating Truth: Semmelweis, Discourse on Hand Hygiene and the Politics of Emotions”. Keynote address at the Semmelweis Lectures of the Annual Conference of the Surgical Infection Society Europe. Vienna (Austria), 6 June 2014.

    Durnová, A. (2013, May). “Lost in Translation: Back and Forth between Fieldwork and Interpretation”. Invited Talk at the Jour Fixe Art & Science, University of Applied Arts. Vienna (Austria), 24 May 2013.

    Durnová, A. (2012, February). “Governing Through Intimacy”. Invited Talk at the Department of Government, University of Essex. Essex (UK), 8 February 2012.

    Durnová, A. (2011). “Über die Rationalität hinaus: Interpretative Politikfeldanalyse. Reaktion auf Andreas Dür”. Keynote address at the Annual Meeting (“Tag der Politikwissenschaft”) of the Austrian Political Studies Association (ÖGPW). University of Salzburg, Salzburg (Austria), 2 December 2011.

    Bargetz, B., Birkner, M., Durnová, A., Hajek, K., Lichtenberger, H., Lorey, I. … Wissen, M. (2011, November). Plenary roundtable: Poststrukturalistische Perspektiven auf Kämpfe”. Conference: Ansteckende Inventionen. Zur Repolitisierung des Poststrukturalismus. Department of Political Science, University of Vienna, Vienna (Austria), 18 November 2011.

    Durnová, A. (2010, November).S’en laver les mains: A propos du mariage de raison entre Science et Politique [“Washing hands: Marriage of Reason betwen Science and Politics”]. Invited talk at the University Franche-Comté. Besancon (France), 3 November 2010.

    Durnová, A. (2010, July). “Science and Politics: a reasonable marriage”. Keynote address at the International Summer School of Philosophy and Social Sciences (OFRESS). Faculty of Arts, University of Belgrade, Belgrade (Serbia), 18 July 2010.

    Durnová, A. (2009, July). “L’Etat face aux catastrophes morales. Memento mori dans la politique française” [“State facing moral catastrophes: memento mori in French politics”]. Keynote address at the International Summer School of Philosophy and Social Sciences (OFRESS). Université Toulouse Mirail, Toulouse (France), 13 July 2009.

    Durnová, A. (2009, November). “Feldforschung intim: Zwischen Erlebnissen, Kategorien und Analyse. Interpretative Politikfeldanalyse” [“Fieldwork intimately: Between Impression, Categories and Analysis. Interpretive Political Science”]. Invited Talk at the Department of Political Science and Sociology, University of Salzburg. Salzburg (Austria), 18 November 2009.

    Durnová, A. (2007, November). “Global Governance of genomics. A phronetic response”. Keynote address at Testing genes, profiling DNA: The global governance of genomics – hopes, duties, and security. Mendel Centre Brno, Brno (Czech Republic), 3 November 2007.

    Durnová, A. (2005, July). “Vers une argumentation authentique” [“Towards an Authentic Argumentation”]. Invited paper presentation at the École Normale Supérieure. Paris (France), 12 July 2005.

     

    Interview mit Anna Durnová über die Jury Entscheidung des Dokumentarfilmfestivals Ji.hlava - Sektion "Politik" The silence of the others,  Radio Praha, 6.11. 2018

    Die Lektion ignaz Semmelweis, Forschungsreport über Anna Durnová, Die Presse ( von Alice Grancy) https://diepresse.com/home/science/dissertation/5417720/Junge-Forschung_Die-Lektion-des-Ignaz-Semmelweis, 5.5. 2018

    Durnová, A., D. Rychnovská (2018): Padá planeta, něco si přej!, https://archiv.ihned.cz/c1-66332870-pada-planeta-neco-si-prej, Hospodářské noviny , 9.11. 2018

    Durnová, A., H. Hönigmayer and J. Starkbaum  (2018): Elga gehört den Bürgern – lasst sie mitreden! https://derstandard.at/2000079118035/Elga-gehoert-den-Buergern-Lasst-sie-mitreden, 4.5. 2018.

    Durnová, A. (2017) Výchova expertů v Čechách,  [„The education of experts in the Czech Republic“], http://a2larm.cz/2017/08/vychova-expertu-v-cechach/, 5.8. 2017

    Durnová, A. (2016): Naděje na zdraví jako věc veřejná, [„Hope to be cured as a public cause“], A2alarm: http://a2larm.cz/2016/06/nadeje-na-zdravi-jako-vec-verejna/ , 7.6.2016

    Durnová, A. (2016) Jak je ti, Rakousko? [„How are you, Austria?“] Nový Prostor 2016/478, http://www.novyprostor.cz/clanky/478/jak-je-ti-rakousko.html

    Durnová (2015): Osudová špína na rukou,[„The fatal dirt on the hands“] Nový Prostor 2015/ 452,  http://www.novyprostor.cz/clanky/452/osudova-spina-na-rukou.html

    Durnová, A. (2015): Lékaři bez hranic odpovědnosti ,[„Doctors without borders of responsibility"], A2alarm: http://a2larm.cz/2015/08/lekari-bez-hranic-odpovednosti/

    (2016, September 15) Eine Bank für Gewebe, Blut und Daten, Interview im Mittagsjournal von Ö1 mit Anna Durnová und Kurt Zatloukal, Retrieved from  science.orf.at/stories/2796798

    Durnová, A. (2014, November 11). 1989: Erinnerungen eines einstigen Kindes (Kommentar der anderen). Der Standard. Retrieved from http://derstandard.at/2000008218368/1989-Erinnerungen-eines-einstigen-Kindes

    Durnová, A. (2013, October 23). Zwischen Populismus und politischer Obdachlosigkeit (Kommentar der anderen). Der Standard. Retrieved from http://derstandard.at/1381369627619/Zwischen-Populismus-und-politischer-Obdachlosigkeit

    Durnová, A., & K. C. Zahradnik (2010, November 2). Wie der Politische Diskurs die Wissenschaft bedroht. Die Presse. Retrieved from http://diepresse.com/home/meinung/gastkommentar/606669/Wie-der-politische-Diskurs-die-Wissenschaft-bedroht?from=suche.intern.portal

     

    ELSI Common Service, BBMRI-ERIC

    Contracted expert

    Project duration: 2016 - 2019

    Project objectives: BBMRI-ERIC is a European research infrastructure for biobanking. Bringing together all the main players from the biobanking field – researchers, biobankers, industry, and patients – to boost biomedical research, the project offers a ELSI Common service to examine and analyse ethical legal and social impacts of data storage and data sharing. IHS part in this project is to focus on various public egnagement templates and strategies that problematize biomedical research in Austria and that uncover values and cultural norms that coproduce the view on what biobanking should be and how the governance should be developed.

    We run focus groups, expert discussions to understand the dynamic of public engagement. ELSI Commonservice is also one of the case studies of the project SECCON of Dagmar Rychnovská.

    Negotiating Truth: Semmelweis, Discourse on Hand Hygiene and the Politics of Emotions (Principal Investigator)

    Project Duration: 2012-2018

    Project objective: “Post-Truth” was pronounced the word of the year in 2016. What followed was a vivid defence of truth by scientists, journalists, and politicians. It seems we are on our way to abandoning the notion of truth as we know it if we consider the populist uprising turning Western liberal democracies upside down and the critique of academic knowledge during Brexit debate or coming from the Trump administration. Scientists should raise their voices against the trend, and civil society should fight post-factualism.

    Yet, exactly what should be said and done? Along examples of performance of scientific truth in public discourse, the project develops the argument that liberal democratic policy regimes lost the battle on truth a while ago. It examines truth as ‘sound knowledge’ - seen as the cornerstone of liberal democratic government - through the lenses of emotions. Conceptualized through cultural sociology and critical policy studies emotions are defined as performances of values and beliefs. Emotions enter evidence-making, they evaluate the range of actors and make them entitled to pronounce public concerns, and as such have to be recognized as integral parts of knowledge-making with an impact on policy processes.

    Financing: Funded by the Hertha-Firnberg Programme of the Austrian FWF Science Fund (TG592-G15)

     

     „Ignaz Semmelweis – Pioneer and Visionary in Medicine“ was made at the occasion of his 200th birthday by Carola Timmel, Simon Casetti, Wolfgang Bledl and Lisa Lerchbacher. Among others, they visited the great-grandson of Semmelweis, who works now as cardiologist there. The film was shown at the symposium „200 Jahre Semmelweis“. Anna Durnová was als part of this film.